module Syndicate.Dataspace.Trie.ESOP2016 where -- Implementation of dataspace tries, following our ESOP 2016 paper, -- "Coordinated Concurrent Programming in Syndicate" (Tony -- Garnock-Jones and Matthias Felleisen). -- -- Includes bug fixes wrt the paper: -- -- - combine now has parameters leftEmpty and rightEmpty. In the -- paper, these were missing, and in some cases combine could fail -- to terminate, since it had missing "br(∅)" checks. -- -- - we use the smart constructor `tl` throughout, to avoid -- constructing `Tl` atop an empty trie. In the paper, this can -- happen in the definition of `get` when `get(h,★)` is the empty -- trie, but σ=<< and no mapping for σ exists in h. -- -- Also, there are problems with the algorithm as described; it is -- roughly correct, but does not collapse away as much redundancy as -- it could. These problems are remedied in ESOP2016v2.hs. -- -- Here is an example of a pair of inputs that could be given to -- combine() as written in the paper that would cause nontermination: -- combine (Tl (Ok (Set.singleton 1))) (Br Map.empty) f_union -- To see the nontermination, comment out the lines -- g r1 r2 | null r1 = dedup $ leftEmpty r2 -- g r1 r2 | null r2 = dedup $ rightEmpty r1 -- from combine below. import Prelude hiding (null, seq) import qualified Data.Map.Strict as Map import qualified Data.Set as Set data Sigma = Open | Close | Wild | Ch Char deriving (Eq, Ord, Show) data Trie a = Ok a | Tl (Trie a) | Br (Map.Map Sigma (Trie a)) deriving (Eq, Show) empty = Br Map.empty null (Br h) = Map.null h null _ = False tl r = if null r then empty else Tl r untl (Tl r) = r untl _ = empty route [] (Ok v) f = v route [] _ f = f route (_ : _) (Ok v) f = f route (x : s) (Br h) f = if Map.null h then f else route s (get h x) f route (Close : s) (Tl r) f = route s r f route (Open : s) (Tl r) f = route s (tl (tl r)) f route (x : s) (Tl r) f = route s (tl r) f get h x = case Map.lookup x h of Just r -> r Nothing -> case x of Open -> tl (get h Wild) Close -> untl (get h Wild) Wild -> empty x -> get h Wild combine r1 r2 f leftEmpty rightEmpty = g r1 r2 where g (Tl r1) (Tl r2) = tl (g r1 r2) g (Tl r1) r2 = g (expand r1) r2 g r1 (Tl r2) = g r1 (expand r2) g (Ok v) r2 = f (Ok v) r2 g r1 (Ok v) = f r1 (Ok v) g r1 r2 | null r1 = dedup $ leftEmpty r2 g r1 r2 | null r2 = dedup $ rightEmpty r1 g (Br h1) (Br h2) = dedup $ Br (foldKeys g h1 h2) foldKeys g h1 h2 = Set.foldr f Map.empty keys where f x acc = Map.insert x (g (get h1 x) (get h2 x)) acc keys = Set.union (Map.keysSet h1) (Map.keysSet h2) expand r = Br (Map.fromList [(Wild, tl r), (Close, r)]) dedup (Br h) = Br (Map.filterWithKey (distinct h) h) distinct h Wild r = not (null r) distinct h Open (Tl r) = r /= get h Wild distinct h Open r = not (null r) distinct h Close r = r /= untl (get h Wild) distinct h x r = r /= get h Wild --------------------------------------------------------------------------- union r1 r2 = combine r1 r2 unionCombine id id unionCombine (Ok vs) (Ok ws) = Ok (Set.union vs ws) unionCombine r1 r2 | null r1 = r2 unionCombine r1 r2 | null r2 = r1 unions rs = foldr union empty rs